Are jews allowed to be gay
Home / gay topics / Are jews allowed to be gay
This article explores the intersection of homosexuality and Judaism, examining scriptural interpretations, historical context, and contemporary developments.
Traditional Jewish Teachings on Homosexuality
The Torah, the foundational text of Judaism, includes specific passages addressing same-sex relationships. Gay marriage was endorsed by the rabbinate in 1996 and by the movement’s congregational arm the following year.
HUC ordained its first openly transgender rabbi in 2006. Arguments include:
- Cultural Context: The Levitical prohibitions may reflect concerns specific to ancient Israel rather than universal moral principles.
- Focus on Holiness: Some interpretations view the text’s emphasis on holiness and distinctiveness as central, rather than specific prohibitions.
- Ethical Priorities: Progressive Jewish thought often prioritizes principles of love, justice, and human dignity over literal adherence to ancient laws.
Conclusion
The relationship between homosexuality and Judaism reflects the dynamic interplay between tradition and modernity.
Israel has regularly touted its achievements on gay rights as a sign of its progressive Western worldview, a practice some critics have derided as an attempt at “pinkwashing” — that is, to distract from its treatment of the Palestinians.
For more on LGBTQ Jewish life, visit MyJewishLearning’s Keshet blog.
Sign Up for Our Newsletter
Get Jewish wisdom & discovery in your inbox
Judaism, one of the world’s oldest monotheistic religions, has a long and complex history of addressing human relationships, including homosexuality.
In addition, many Jewish institutions — including summer camps — have begun taking steps to accommodate and welcome transgender Jews.
As JTA reported in April 2016, “even in the Orthodox world, which presents the most barriers to transgender acceptance, both culturally and in Jewish law, some community figures are talking about the need to find a place for trans Jews.”
To read this article, “Jewish Views on Homosexuality,” in Spanish (leer en Español), click here.
Sign Up for Our Newsletter
Get Jewish wisdom & discovery in your inbox
As social attitudes toward lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ) people have undergone a sea change globally, stances taken by Jewish leaders and movements have changed along with them.
Today, same-sex marriages are recognized by the Reform, Conservative, Renewal and Reconstructionist movements, and each movement’s rabbinical seminary ordains LGBTQ students.
However, later rabbinic authorities expanded the prohibition to include lesbian sexual acts and all male homosexual activities short of anal intercourse. Other Conservative rabbis, believing that gay marriage must enjoy the same status as traditional heterosexual marriage, have insisted on applying the traditional marriage rituals with only the most minor modifications in gendered language.
Orthodox rabbis on the whole do not perform same-sex marriages.
While traditional texts contain prohibitions, contemporary movements within Judaism emphasize inclusion, dignity, and the evolving understanding of human sexuality. Two verses in Leviticus (Leviticus 18:23 and Leviticus 20:13) express unequivocal condemnation of male homosexual sex (although it is not clear whether what is referred to is intercourse or all sexual acts between men).
While there is little indication that this position is severely contested within that community, let alone likely to change in the near future, there have been initiatives to make Orthodox communities more welcoming of gay Jews. A statement authored in 2010 and signed by over 200 Orthodox rabbis expressly welcomed gay Jews fully into synagogue life even as it reiterated traditional Orthodox opposition to gay sex and same-sex marriage.
However, rabbinic literature often focused more on community cohesion than individual punishment.
- Talmudic Discussions: The Talmud, a central text in Rabbinic Judaism, offers limited commentary on homosexuality, focusing instead on broader issues of morality and legal precedent.
- Medieval and Early Modern Views: Jewish scholars during these periods often adhered to traditional interpretations of Leviticus, reflecting the broader societal attitudes of their times.
Modern Movements and Changing Attitudes
In the modern era, the diverse branches of Judaism have developed varying stances on homosexuality:
- Orthodox Judaism:
- Orthodox Judaism generally maintains a traditional interpretation of Levitical prohibitions, viewing homosexual acts as against Jewish law.
- Despite this, some Orthodox communities emphasize compassion and inclusion, focusing on the dignity and humanity of LGBTQ+ individuals.
- Conservative Judaism:
- Conservative Judaism has undergone significant changes in its approach to homosexuality.
- In 2006, the Conservative Movement’s Committee on Jewish Law and Standards issued rulings permitting the ordination of openly gay and lesbian rabbis and the recognition of same-sex relationships, while still upholding traditional interpretations for those who choose to follow them.
- Reform Judaism:
- Reform Judaism, emphasizing ethical principles over ritual law, has been at the forefront of LGBTQ+ inclusion.
- The movement supports same-sex marriage, ordination of LGBTQ+ clergy, and full acceptance of LGBTQ+ individuals within Jewish life.
- Reconstructionist and Humanistic Judaism:
- These progressive movements embrace LGBTQ+ inclusion as part of their commitment to social justice and equality.
- They affirm the diversity of sexual orientations and gender identities as part of human dignity and expression.
LGBTQ+ Inclusion in Jewish Communities
Across Jewish communities, efforts have been made to create inclusive spaces for LGBTQ+ individuals.
Orthodox seminaries still do not permit openly gay students; however there is at least one Orthodox gay rabbi who came out subsequent to his ordination.
How is the LGBTQ community treated in Israel?
By many metrics, Israel is considered a trailblazer on LGBTQ issues. Key initiatives include:
- Supportive Organizations: Groups like Keshet and Eshel provide resources and advocacy for LGBTQ+ Jews.
- Inclusive Rituals: Many communities have developed rituals and liturgies to celebrate same-sex unions and other milestones in LGBTQ+ lives.
- Education and Dialogue: Programs addressing sexuality and gender identity from a Jewish perspective aim to foster understanding and acceptance.
Scriptural Reinterpretation and Debate
Modern scholars and theologians have reexamined traditional texts through the lens of historical context and contemporary values.
However, it is important to note:
- Context: Levitical laws were part of a broader set of rules governing ritual purity and societal order in ancient Israel.
- Focus on Male Relationships: The text does not explicitly address female same-sex relationships, leading to varied interpretations within Jewish tradition.
Historical Perspectives on Homosexuality in Judaism
In ancient Jewish communities, the emphasis on family, procreation, and societal structure influenced attitudes toward sexuality.
In addition, the Reform movement approves of rabbinic officiation at same-sex marriages and commitment ceremonies.
READ: Denominational Approaches on Ordaining Openly Gay and Lesbian Rabbis
Daniel Siegel, the Rabbinic Director of ALEPH: Alliance for Jewish Renewal, has endorsed same-sex marriage specifically because he believes that holiness should not be limited only to certain people and certain relationships.
By fostering dialogue and embracing diversity, Jewish communities continue to navigate this complex and deeply personal aspect of identity.
Related
Some in the Orthodox community still support conversion therapy, however, in part because they believe it is impossible that homosexual desires could be both unchangeable and proscribed by the Torah.
Numerous organizations and support groups exist for gay Jews who are interested in maintaining a traditional Jewish lifestyle.
A decade later, the Conservative movement reversed its longstanding ban on gay sexual activity and reversed its policy of not ordaining gay and lesbian rabbis. In Judaism, one is only responsible for religious obligations that one can freely choose to fulfill.
Steven Greenberg, a gay Jewish educator who was ordained as an Orthodox rabbi, writes and lectures on the possibilities for gays and lesbians in the Orthodox community.